[lacnog] y la libertad... Twitter officially shutdown in Pakistan - Twitter Banned in Pakistan

Lun Mayo 21 20:22:57 BRT 2012

On 5/21/12 8:10 PM, Nicolás Ruiz wrote:
> Gracias por la explicación. Me sospechaba algo por el estilo, solo que
> he escuchado en otras partes que la posición de "gobiernos, empresas y
> banqueros saben lo que la gente necesita de Internet" se parece más a
> la posición de la ICANN. En todo caso soy el primero en admitir que no
> tengo nada clara la situación actual de gobernabilidad de Internet.

Interesante debate.

Hay grises, obviamente, entre la postura que reafirma las bondades del 
modelo de autorregulación (Multistakeholder de Gobernanza de Internet) y 
las de los Estados Emergentes.

Latinoamérica tiene posturas tomadas en defensa del primero, pero hay 
matices de muchos tipos.

Quizás sea hora que LACNIC ponga un workshop, además del que hubo en 
Quito sobre WCIT (uno de los tratados de UIT en Dubai de este año), 
sobre Gobernanza de Internet. Sería bueno que los miembros de esta 
comunidad (Operadores) y del resto del ambiente técnico, puedan sentirse 
atraidos para participar del debate de la Gobernanza de Internet (las 
reuniones preparatorias regionales especialmente). Tienen mucho que aportar.

Andrés Piazza

>
> On Mon, May 21, 2012 at 7:42 AM, Tomas Lynch<tomas.lynch en gmail.com>  wrote:
>> Nicolás,
>>
>> La cuestión sobre quién debe o cómo se debe gobernar Internet
>> (gobernabilidad) es un debate que desde hace rato está en la ITU. Las
>> posiciones en resumidas cuentas son, por favor corrijame alguien más
>> experot en el tema: "dejemos todo como está que Internet es
>> autoregulable por sus mismos usuarios", IETF, o "los gobiernos,
>> empresas y banqueros saben muy bien lo que la gente necesita de
>> Internet", ITU.
>>
>> Mi opinión es que lo único que hizo bien la ITU fué ISIS y eso fué
>> porque despues pasó por un RFC. La ITU es un organismo dependiente de
>> la ONU y ya sabemos cómo trabaja ese organismo donde todo depende de
>> razones económicas (e.g.¿por qué en el eje del mal está Corea del
>> Norte y no estaba Libia? ¿ por qué existe Médicos Sin Fronteras cuando
>> está la Cruz Roja?)
>>
>> No sigo porque es lunes.
>>
>> Tomás
>>
>> On Sun, May 20, 2012 at 9:04 PM, Nicolás Ruiz<nicoruiz en gmail.com>  wrote:
>>> Podrías extenderte en tu opinion? No entiendo de lo que hablas, no uso
>>> twitter y no entiendo los tags como #wsis.
>>>
>>> On Sun, May 20, 2012 at 1:59 PM, Carlos Martinez
>>> <carlosmarcelomartinez en gmail.com>  wrote:
>>>> Una razón mas para pensar bien cuando llegue el momento de elegir bandos.
>>>>
>>>> Internet regulada por un grupo de países que incluye India, Rusia, kazajstan?
>>>>
>>>> Los que ni entienden de que hablo y todavía tienen twitter puede seguir #wsis
>>>>
>>>> S2
>>>>
>>>> Carlos
>>>>
>>>> Sent from a mobile device
>>>>
>>>> On May 20, 2012, at 2:09 PM, Erick Iriarte Ahon<eiriarte en alfa-redi.org>  wrote:
>>>>
>>>>> SUNDAY, MAY 20, 2012
>>>>> Source: http://www.internetsgovernance.blogspot.com/2012/05/twitter-officially-shutdown-in-pakistan.html
>>>>>
>>>>> Twitter officially shutdown in Pakistan - Twitter Banned in Pakistan
>>>>>
>>>>> As of 20th May 2012, Pakistan Telecommunication Authority PTA with permission from the Ministry of Information Technology MoIT upon the suggestion of PTA's Director General for Strategy and Development has allowed the full and blanket shutdown of the worlds most famous Social Media and Microblogging website Twitter.com to its audience in Pakistan. According to authorities, they had contacted Twitter.com to remove all offensive religious material but it has failed to comply to do so thus Twitter.com has been officially shutdown across Pakistan!
>>>>>
>>>>> So far the news coming from various sources share that this has been done in lieu of raising awareness against the religious and contentious online content that was floated on Facebook on 20th May. The authorities are taking this step to register that no such activity will be tolerated that is against the religious sentiments of the citizens of Pakistan. This ban and shutdown of Twitter.com is intended to convince foreign companies and Internet Content providers globally to remove all such religiously offensive content to Muslims.
>>>>>
>>>>> The Daily DAWN (Pakistan) reports here the Chairman PTA Dr. Yaseen has put the blame that the orders came from the Ministry of Information Technology MoIT Government of Pakistan yesterday on 19th May 2020. The reality of the situation is that this ban is believed to be suggested by a PTA official present during the meeting at the MoIT.
>>>>>
>>>>> According to another report by the Associated Press, Dr. Yaseen stated that they had been negotiating with Twitter until last night, but they did not agree to remove the stuff, so they had to block it whereas the instructions to block the site came from Pakistan’s Ministry of Information Technology and the ministry officials are still trying to make Twitter agree, and once they remove that objected material  the site is expected to be unblocked.
>>>>>
>>>>> The Express Tribute reports here that MoIT has claimed that it attempted getting through to Twitter authorities and sent five faxes to the micro-blogging website but Twitter responded by saying that they “cannot stop any individual doing anything of this nature on the website”.
>>>>>
>>>>> Various sources also reported that the Interior Minister Rehman Malik tweeted earlier in the morning that the government had no plans to impose restrictions on Twitter and Facebook assuring the citizens of Pakistan that both Twitter and Facebook will continue to be accessible throughout Pakistan. He also told his twitter stream followers not to believe in rumours. The Minister also remarked to a New York Times reporter's question claiming that there are reports that the government intended to restrict access to Twitter by saying that "Why (should) I even think of doing so?". PK Politics Blog posted a screenshot of the Minister's Tweets:
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> Image from the PK Politics Blog here
>>>>>
>>>>> The Pakistani electronic media has quoted the Minister of IT Raja Parvez Ashraf that the government could restrict access to Twitter and Facebook as the sites were being used to circulate blasphemous caricatures. Last night, rumors were circulating that Facebook.com will also be shutdown as well as Google. Facebook.com was not taking strong steps to remove religiously offensive content to Muslims and Google.com was still bringing up searches and links to such content online.
>>>>>
>>>>> The authorities claim to be in direct contact with the responsible personnel at Twitter.com and Facebook.com. Mark Zuckerberg already has a warrant for arrest in Pakistan and should be careful incase he wants to visit Pakistan for his honeymoon. On the other hand, PTA and MoIT continue to take positions for the citizen of Pakistan without consulting them through a multistakeholder or public consultation process. All such attempts have been backfiring on the reputation of Pakistan's Information Society and Regulators tainting it in the global Knowledge Economy.
>>>>>
>>>>> Twitter.com is used by the Civil Society and Citizens of Pakistan to express their personal thoughts and opinions and the total blanket shutdown of Twitter.com is a fundamental human right violation preventing Pakistani Citizens both online and offline to express themselves using the Internet through their personal computers and mobile phone devices. Authorities are restricting access to Twitter.com without consulting the citizens of Pakistan through multistakeholder processes.
>>>>>
>>>>> So far the the whole world and audience on the web is mocking Twitter.com's shutdown in Pakistan . The Internet and World Wide Web is flooded the world over with this news as Pakistan joins the league of countries that ban twitter.com and are considered to be repressing Freedom of Expression.
>>>>> Related articles
>>>>>
>>>>>     • Pakistan blocks Twitter over contentious material (seattlepi.com)
>>>>>     • Pakistan blocks Twitter over contentious material (seattletimes.nwsource.com)
>>>>>     • Twitter banned in Pakistan (dawn.com)
>>>>>     • Pakistan blocks Twitter over 'offensive' material (foxnews.com)
>>>>>     • Report: Pakistan Blocks Twitter Over Blasphemous Content, Facebook Complies? (techcrunch.com)
>>>>>     • Pakistan blocks Twitter because of material considered offensive to Islam (foxnews.com)
>>>>>     • Pakistan Blocks Twitter Over Contentious Material (abcnews.go.com)
>>>>>     • Pakistan blocks Twitter over contentious material (mysanantonio.com)
>>>>>     • Pakistan blocks Twitter (thehindu.com)
>>>>>     • Pakistan Blocks Twitter Over 'Blasphemy' (news.sky.com)
>>>>>
>>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>>> LACNOG mailing list
>>>>> LACNOG en lacnic.net
>>>>> https://mail.lacnic.net/mailman/listinfo/lacnog
>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>> LACNOG mailing list
>>>> LACNOG en lacnic.net
>>>> https://mail.lacnic.net/mailman/listinfo/lacnog
>>>
>>>
>>> --
>>> Key fingerprint = E6A9 91D9 F47E 8A0B 5A91  DAED 131D CFBC ED36 0956
>>> Old fingerprint = CDA7 9892 50F7 22F8 E379  08DA 9A3B 194B D641 C6FF
>>> _______________________________________________
>>> LACNOG mailing list
>>> LACNOG en lacnic.net
>>> https://mail.lacnic.net/mailman/listinfo/lacnog
>> _______________________________________________
>> LACNOG mailing list
>> LACNOG en lacnic.net
>> https://mail.lacnic.net/mailman/listinfo/lacnog
>
>