[LACNIC/Politicas] Nueva propuesta LAC-2019-12 / Nova proposta LAC-2019-12 / New proposal LAC-2019-12

Mon Nov 18 09:44:43 -02 2019

Hola Fernando,

> Al principio, la propuesta parece interesante, pero antes de poder apoyarla me 
> gustaría poder leer el análisis de impacto del staff, ya que tengo algunas dudas 
> sobre la implementación de esto en los servidores de LACNIC.
> Puede ser engañoso para mí en algunos detalles, pero debido a la sparse 
> allocation que realiza RIR, para generar cada ROA puede ocupar un gran espacio 
> en los servidores de LACNIC y solo quiero conocer el punto de vista del staff 
> antes de poder continuar.

entiendo la preocupación, pero un ROA puede tener más que uno solo bloque, y con 
eso no seria una preocupación el hecho de haber muchos rangos no consecutivos 
libres.
todos podría estar uno solo ROA.

saludos

> Saludos
> Fernando
> 
> On 13/11/2019 10:00, info-politicas at lacnic.net wrote:
>> [Português abaixo]
>> [English below]
>>
>> Estimados suscriptores de la Lista de Políticas de LACNIC,
>>
>> Se recibió una nueva propuesta de Política, se le asignó el id LAC-2019-12.
>>
>> Título: RPKI ASN 0 ROA
>>
>> Resumen: When using RPKI an organization can issue a Routing Origin 
>> Authorization, ROA, that indicate a set of address block that can be announced 
>> with origin an a specific ASN also indicated in it.
>> Other organizations also using RPKI can use that information to make decisions 
>> about withe route announcements are legit and with are not.
>>
>> It is also possible to issue a ROA with ASN 0 (zero) in its ASid field to sign 
>> that address blocks in it should be be accepted.
>>
>> This policy proposal recommend LACNIC to issue ASN 0 ROAs, with unallocated 
>> and unassigned addresses block in it, as a method to indicate that route 
>> announcements with those addresses should be not accepted by networks using 
>> RPKI Routing Origin Validation (ROV),
>>
>> Para ver el detalle ingrese en:
>> https://politicas.lacnic.net/politicas/detail/id/LAC-2019-12
>>
>> Los comentarios y los puntos de vista aportados por la comunidad son vitales 
>> para el correcto desarrollo del proceso de la propuestas
>> - ¿Apoya usted o se opone a esta propuesta?
>> - ¿Esta propuesta resolvería un problema que usted está experimentando?- ¿Ve 
>> alguna desventaja en esta propuesta?
>> - ¿Qué cambios podrían hacerse a esta propuesta para que sea más eficaz?
>>
>> Por más información contacte a info-politicas at lacnic.net
>> Saludos cordiales,
>>
>> ______________________________________________________________________________________________________ 
>>
>>
>> Prezados assinantes da lista de políticas de LACNIC,
>>
>> Foi recebida uma nova proposta de Política, foi atribuído o id LAC-2019-12.
>>
>> Título: RPKI ASN 0 ROA
>>
>> Resumo: When using RPKI an organization can issue a Routing Origin 
>> Authorization, ROA, that indicate a set of address block that can be announced 
>> with origin an a specific ASN also indicated in it.
>> Other organizations also using RPKI can use that information to make decisions 
>> about withe route announcements are legit and with are not.
>>
>> It is also possible to issue a ROA with ASN 0 (zero) in its ASid field to sign 
>> that address blocks in it should be be accepted.
>>
>> This policy proposal recommend LACNIC to issue ASN 0 ROAs, with unallocated 
>> and unassigned addresses block in it, as a method to indicate that route 
>> announcements with those addresses should be not accepted by networks using 
>> RPKI Routing Origin Validation (ROV),
>>
>> Para ver o detalhe acesse:
>> https://politicas.lacnic.net/politicas/detail/id/LAC-2019-12
>>
>>   Os comentários e os pontos de vista aportados pela comunidade são vitais 
>> para o bom desenvolvimento do processo das propostas
>> - ¿Você é a favor ou contra desta proposta?
>> - ¿Esta proposta iria resolver um problema que você está experimentando?- ¿Vê 
>> alguma alguma desvantagem nesta proposta?
>> - ¿Que mudanças poderiam ser feitas à proposta para que seja mais eficaz?
>>
>>   Por mais informações entre em contato conosco através do seguinte e-mail: 
>> info-politicas at lacnic.net
>> Atenciosamente,
>> ______________________________________________________________________________________________________ 
>>
>>
>> Dear LACNIC Policy List subscribers,
>>
>> A new Policy Proposal has been received and assigned the following ID: 
>> LAC-2019-12.
>>
>> Title: RPKI ASN 0 ROA
>>
>> Summary: When using RPKI an organization can issue a Routing Origin 
>> Authorization, ROA, that indicate a set of address block that can be announced 
>> with origin an a specific ASN also indicated in it.
>> Other organizations also using RPKI can use that information to make decisions 
>> about withe route announcements are legit and with are not.
>>
>> It is also possible to issue a ROA with ASN 0 (zero) in its ASid field to sign 
>> that address blocks in it should be be accepted.
>>
>> This policy proposal recommend LACNIC to issue ASN 0 ROAs, with unallocated 
>> and unassigned addresses block in it, as a method to indicate that route 
>> announcements with those addresses should be not accepted by networks using 
>> RPKI Routing Origin Validation (ROV),
>>
>> To read the proposal, please go to
>> https://politicas.lacnic.net/politicas/detail/id/LAC-2019-12
>>
>> The community's comments and opinions are essential to the proper functioning 
>> of the policy development process.
>> - Do you support this policy or are you against it?
>> - Would this proposal solve a problem you are experiencing?- Do you think this 
>> proposal has any drawbacks?
>> - What changes could be made to this proposal to make it more effective?
>>
>> For further information, please contact info-politicas at lacnic.net
>> Kind regards,
>>
>> 
>> --LACNIC - Latin American and Caribbean Internet Addresses Registry
>> Rambla Rep. de México 6125, CP 11400
>> Montevideo-Uruguay
>> Phone number: +598 2604 22 22
>> www.lacnic.net
>>
>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> Politicas mailing list
>> Politicas at lacnic.net
>> https://mail.lacnic.net/mailman/listinfo/politicas
> _______________________________________________
> Politicas mailing list
> Politicas at lacnic.net
> https://mail.lacnic.net/mailman/listinfo/politicas