[lacnog] Subasignación de prefijos a otro ASN y el tema con los RoA

[Rubens Kuhl]

> I apologize for mixing LACNIC and LACNOG.
> You posted something from Brazil.
> As far as I know Brazil has had a law requiring addresses utilized in Brazil
> to be registered at NIC.br.
> This is fairly unique, possibly only China also has this requirement as far
> as I know.

There is no such law in Brazil. The only law about Internet here is
called "Marco Civil", and you can see that in English here:
https://www.cgi.br/pagina/marco-civil-law-of-the-internet-in-brazil/180

You can see at IX.br, the Internet Exchange matrix operated by NIC.br,
many ARIN, RIPE or other allocation sources, many route announcements
of IP blocks not allocated by NIC.br.


> Nonetheless this is not a policy requirement of LACNIC.

Not a policy requirement but an RSA requirement, as you mentioned below.

> LACNIC assignments will not reveal LACNIC lessees, whose assignments may be
> done at another RIR.

That's fine. If other RIRs allocated the blocks, their policies are
the one that matters. All RIRs are happy with that.

> I would wait a bit for the private messages, but I am sure you will learn
> that leased addresses do not have to be legacy and leasing addresses is not
> against policy in ARIN, RIPE, or APNIC.

Next time I bump into John Curran I am sure to ask him about ARIN,
because I read him stating otherwise in NANOG.


> LACNIC and AFRINIC alone among the RIRs have maintained in their RSAs the
> ability to revoke for utilization outside the original justification, or for
> lack of utilization.  Likely this is one of the causes of Latin America's
> very small transfer market. AFRINIC hasn't run out completely yet, so their
> market is non-existent. The other trading RIRs understood that maintaining
> this revocation ability runs counter to a functioning IPv4 market.

This ability is exactly what allows us to run an honest system where
people ask for what they need, not for what they will use to make
other people's lives costlier. If that doesn't work for brokers, they
can go elsewhere in the world.

Rubens